Cultural Restitution
SHARE ARTICLE
Although human remains accounted for 69% of all items repatriated by UK institutions during the 12-year period 2010 to 2022, a study led by University College London (UCL) reveals the share of other cultural heritage items repatriated is increasing.
In November, Rachel Gatehouse, a doctoral student at UCL’s Department of Information Studies and the study’s lead researcher, told the Museums Association: “Our analysis shows how the profile of the objects being repatriated is changing, with a more diverse range of items returning to a greater number of countries.”
The study, co-authored by Jin Gao who supervised this research programme, investigated the return of 491 cultural items across 29 case studies and involving seven source countries.
London’s Natural History Museum was responsible for the largest number of these returns (288 items representing 59% of the entire total). The Museum, which holds an enormous collection of some 20,000 human remains, was responsible for 75% of all the human remains repatriated by UK institutions over this 12-year period.
This follows a series of vigorous and well-organised official or government-backed repatriation campaigns (especially by the Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies Return of Cultural Heritage project and the Karanga Aotearoa Repatriation Programme) and it’s no surprise to learn that 97% of all the human remains returned were made to Australia or New Zealand, primarily for reburial.
What did surprise the researchers is an increase, from 2019 onwards, in the number of other cultural artefacts repatriated, including sacred and religious items. Rather than passing into national collections, they noticed more and more of these returns were being made directly to Indigenous source communities, who are now using them in religious ceremonies. This indicates, according to Gatehouse, “a shift away from an item preservation focus and towards a living culture focus”.
The research showed that most of these cultural artefacts had been removed between 1875 and 1910, the height of British colonialism, and were made largely from former British colonies, including India, Canada, New Zealand, Australia, Nigeria and the US. The only non-colonial source country was Ethiopia, from where extensive looting by British forces took place on General Sir Robert Napier’s Abyssinian campaign between 1867 and 1868. Intriguingly, the data indicates a lack of success in attempts to repatriate artefacts from other former British colonies.
Benin artefacts returned to Nigeria represented almost half (48%) of the total of 153 cultural artefacts repatriated over the 12-year period of the study.
However, Jin Gao reveals the rate of returns has been inconsistent, with most years witnessing the repatriation of fewer than 30 artefacts. Larger numbers of artefacts returned in any single year were exceptions to the overall trend.
Nevertheless, the overall upward trend has encouraged Gatehouse to recommend that “sector practice, as well as government policy, should adapt to keep pace with this change”.
The study’s database has been compiled largely from public records. Given inconsistencies in national and regional reporting, it’s quite possible that other returns have not been captured. However, published in Heritage & Society, the study still provides: “a detailed snapshot of the UK’s actual repatriation activity, its trends and patterns,” said Rachel Gatehouse.



